Bummed Out by the Confusion

It's all been said endlessly, in newspapers, CNN, CNBC and the financial blogosphere - there has never been a time of such conflicting data and opinion. People are genuinely being turned off North American equity markets. The tone of US political bickering is discouraging and uninformative. Canadian politics seem designed to put the electorate to sleep and if they wake up, they shut the shop. Out of all this, people are advocating "throw them all out", which is understandable but seem at the same instant to embrace radical positions that if actually enacted, would worsen their own situations, which is not.

On top of this, we have cries of 'treasury bubble', 'gold bubble', scary Hindenburg Omens, what-if "W" scenarios, deflation-inducing de-leverage, closed-door credit, persistent unemployment, flatlined incomes, debt and pension crises, 'I'm OK so far' housing here, debacles elsewhere. No wonder equity investment is declining and people are easily stampeded into bonds at non-existent interest rates, just in the hope of preserving original capital. Theories abound for an imminent further drop in US markets. None, except for general contrarians, call for an advance.

The actions being talked up in America and Europe, if actually pursued to their conclusions will mean at least 2 or 3 years of considerable difficulty for most citizens. In Europe they are already in place. In the US they are not. I believe they will not be enacted there before the Nov. 11 elections and even less so afterwards, despite current claims to the contrary.

Many large corporations have quite decent balance sheets. But the US government, whose actions in conjunction with the US Federal Reserve affect us all, does not. Add to this state revenue shortfalls and the competition to sell bonds by governments to somebody that is NOT the government (unless its foreign), will be intense.

Most recent government financing has been into the short-term market. That means - as a certainty - that in order to raise new money, simultaneously all of the short-term debt has to be rolled over (re-sold) also.

We see that in the short term the economy will be weak and unemployment persistent, so tax revenues will be poor. The new debt numbers will therefore be monumental. If the debt is not sold - and the need will be such as to guarantee fierce competition - it is exceedingly unlikely that rates can be held down. The repeated periods before each major issue will seem like mini-crises.

This not irrational scenario will put huge pressures on North American and European currencies. Commodity sales will help Canada but our currency cannot get so far separated from the USD as to collapse our industrial sector.

Currency changes exist in relation to other things. The best of energy and gold stocks would survive. If as an alternative you want the most secure and liquid direct gold participation, I have previously suggested looking at the Sprott PHYS ETF of Canadian-held physical gold. It trades in USD. Don't switch currencies until you are ready.

Position: Long ARNA-Q, CGG-T, VET.UN-T